Business Strategy and Outlook:
Hotel Property Investments generates predictable and growing revenue, with long-term leases and contracted rental increases getting a boost from the recent uptick in inflation. But the no-moat REIT also faces material risks. The main tenant is highly geared and faces threats from COVID-19 lockdowns and social distancing rules. Overall, the stock is considered to be fairly valued, with fair value estimate of AUD 3.10 per unit. Hotel Property Investments offers a forecast fiscal 2022 yield of 6% with modest growth potential. It has a long weighted average lease term of over 10 years and mostly triple-net leases that see the tenant pay for most property costs, including maintenance capital expenditure. Lease expiries are relatively well spread, with just 13% expiring in the five years to 2026 and a further 40% in the five years thereafter. In fiscal 2021, occupancy was 100%.
Another key positive is that contracted rental growth is high relative to most REIT peers. Two thirds of leases have annual rent uplifts of the lesser of 4% or twice the average of the last five years’ CPI inflation. However, rents reset to fair market rates when leases expire so actual rent growth over the long term is unlikely to be as strong as contracted rental uplifts suggest.
Financial Strength:
Hotel Property Investments’ credit metrics are relatively aggressive, with debt/assets of about 38%. This is significantly higher than peers, such as BWP at less than 20%.
Despite being mostly exposed to Queensland, which has so far experienced only minor impacts from COVID-19, Hotel Property Investments agreed to defer AUD 7.5 million of rent —equivalent to 12% of annual net rental income—for the main tenant for the period from April 2020 to September 2020. In addition, smaller tenants forced to close during lockdowns had rents abated, but this amounted to a negligible AUD 0.1 million in fiscal 2021. Further deferrals and abatements can’t be ruled out as lockdowns are a likely tool to control the spread of new variants. With interest rates currently low, the trust has been actively acquiring properties, including nine in fiscal 2021. The combination of acquisitions and rising property valuations have doubled the value of Hotel Property Investments’ property portfolio in the past eight years. Capitalisation rates are likely to ease lower in the near term to reflect recent market evidence, pushing book values up a little further.
Company Profile:
Hotel Property Investments is an Australian REIT with a portfolio of freehold pub properties primarily in Queensland. Its portfolio is almost exclusively leased to Queensland Venue Company on triple-net long-term leases where the tenant is responsible for outgoings (except land tax in Queensland), resulting in relatively low maintenance expenses. Most leases also provide for annual rental increases typically at the lower of 4% or two times the average of the last five years consumer price index.
(Source: Morningstar)
General Advice Warning
Any advice/ information provided is general in nature only and does not take into account the personal financial situation, objectives or needs of any particular person.
Business Strategy and Outlook
Despite having leading positions in many categories (fruit spreads, peanut butter, dog treats, coffee, and cat food) Morningstar analysts believe that Smucker lacks an economic moat, either via its brand intangible assets or entrenched retail relationships. Morningstar analysis shows that for most of its sales base, Smucker does not possess pricing power and its market shares are slipping. This dilemma cannot be attributed to a lack of support, as Smucker’s brand investments exceed that of its peers and suspected that these expenditures are not as productive as its competitor.
Morningstar analysts expect that Smucker’s organic sales growth will average 2% annually over the long term, and it is also expected that market share in coffee and dog food will persist as Smucker struggles to compete with strong brands such as Starbucks and BLUE. As per Morningstar analyst perspective, Smucker will be one of the few packaged food companies to realize lasting benefits from the pandemic, given the high-single-digit increase in pets adopted during the crisis and the likelihood that more flexible work arrangements should result in higher consumption of at-home coffee. This impact will not be immaterial, as collectively, pet food and coffee compose nearly 70% of Smucker’s sales. Further, Smucker’s sales trajectory should improve as Uncrustables (5% of fiscal 2021 sales) becomes a greater portion of the mix, as the brand has grown double-digits in each of the past several years. In addition, recent and pending divestitures of slower-growing brands (Crisco, Natural Balance, private label dry pet food, juices, and grains) should further improve Smucker’s ability to accelerate its top-line growth.
Financial Strength
After years of a conservatively leveraged balance sheet, with net debt/adjusted EBITDA consistently below 2 times, the Big Heart Pet Brands acquisition in 2015 increased the ratio to above 6. Net debt to adjusted EBITDA was 2.4 times in fiscal 2021. Smucker’s free cash flow as a percentage of revenue has averaged high single digits to low double digits historically and similar results are expected forward also. Smucker seeks to invest half of its capital in growth initiatives (capital expenditures and acquisitions) and return half to stakeholders via dividends, share repurchase, and debt reduction. Morningstar analysts expect that Smucker will invest 3.5% of annual sales in capital expenditures over the long term. Analysts also expect that Smucker will continue to reshape its portfolio through acquisitions and divestitures. The estimated dividend payout ratio will range between 40% and 50%, in line with management’s long-term targets, with forecasts anticipating 2%-6% annual dividend increases. Morningstar analysts also expect Smucker to repurchase 0%-5% of shares annually, which we view as a prudent use of capital if the share price remains below our fair value estimate.
Bulls Say
- Smucker’s sales trajectory should improve over time due to the divestiture of slow-growing brands and the increasing mix of Uncrustables, which grows at a double-digit pace.
- During the pandemic, consumers adopted 11 million pets and purchased 3 million coffee machines, which should provide a lasting benefit for categories representing nearly 70% of Smucker’s fiscal 2021 sales.
- Executive leadership changes (newly created chief operating officer role, leadership changes for the U.S. sales organization and the pet food segment) should improve execution and enhance accountability.
Company Profile
J.M. Smucker is a packaged food company that primarily operates in the U.S. retail channel (88% of fiscal 2021 revenue), but also in U.S. food-service (5%), and international (7%). Its largest segment is pet food and treats (36% of 2021 revenue), with popular brands such as Milk-Bone, Meow Mix, 9Lives, Kibbles ‘n Bits, Nature’s Recipe, and Rachael Ray Nutrish. Its second-largest category is coffee (33% across channels) with the number-two brand Folgers and number-six Dunkin’. Other large categories are peanut butter (10%), with number-one Jif, fruit spreads (5%) with number-one Smucker’s, and frozen hand-held foods (5%) with number-one Uncrustables.
(Source: Morningstar)
General Advice Warning
Any advice/ information provided is general in nature only and does not take into account the personal financial situation, objectives or needs of any particular person.
Business Strategy and Outlook
Tesla is the largest battery electric vehicle automaker in the world. In less than a decade, the company went from a startup to a globally recognized luxury .Tesla also plans to sell multiple new vehicles over the next several years. These include a platform that will be used to make an affordable sedan and SUV, a light truck, a semi truck, and a sports car.
Tesla’s strategy is to maintain its market leader status as EVs grow from a niche auto market to reaching mass consumer adoption. To do so, the company is undergoing a massive capacity expansion to increase the number of vehicles it can produce. Tesla also invests around 5% of its sales in research and development, focusing on improving its market-leading technology and reducing its manufacturing costs. For EVs to see mass adoption, they need to reach cost and function parity with internal combustion engines. To reduce costs, Tesla focuses on automation and efficiency in its manufacturing process.To reach functional parity, EV will need to have adequate range, reduced charging times, and availability of charging infrastructure.Tesla continues to grow its supercharging network, which consists of fast chargers built along highways and in cities throughout the U.S., EU, and China. The company is attempting to take a larger share of its customers’ auto-related spending, which includes selling insurance and offering paid services such as autonomous driving functions.
Tesla also sells solar panels and batteries used for energy storage to consumers and utilities. As the solar generation and battery storage market expands, Tesla is well positioned to grow.
Raising Tesla FVE to $700 on Higher Near-Term Vehicle Volumes; Shares Remain Overvalued
On Jan. 2, Tesla reported strong fourth-quarter and full-year vehicle delivery numbers. On the year, Tesla reported 936,172 vehicles delivered, which is up over 87% year on year versus 2020. Morningstar analyst have updated our model to incorporate higher 2021 sales volumes and have raised our outlook for 2022 as well as forecasted that Telsa will deliver a little over 1.5 million vehicles in 2022, which represents over 60% year-on-year growth. Separately, Morningstar analyst have decreased 2022 gross margin forecast for Tesla as they increased production costs associated with the opening of the two new production plants in Austin, Texas, (U.S.) and in Berlin, Germany. Our long-term outlook is largely unchanged as we continue to expect Tesla’s sales growth will slow. Having updated model to reflect these changes, Morningstar analyst have increased Tesla fair value estimate to $700 per share from $680.
Financial Strength
Tesla is in solid financial health as cash and cash equivalents exceeded total debt as of Sept. 30. Total debt was roughly $8.2 billion; however, total debt excluding vehicle and energy product financing (nonrecourse debt) was around $2.1 billion. Cash and cash equivalents stood at $16.1 billion as of Sept. 30.To fund its growth plans, Tesla has used credit lines, convertible debt financing, and equity offerings to raise capital. In 2020, the company raised $12.3 billion in three equity issuances. Morningstar analyst thinks this makes sense as funding massive growth solely through debt adds near-term risk in a cyclical industry.Management has stated a preference to pay down all debt over time and continues to make progress on this goal. Regardless, with positive free cash flow generation and a clean balance sheet, we think Tesla could maintain its current levels
Bull Says
- Tesla has the potential to disrupt the automotive and power generation industries with its technology for EVs, AVs, batteries, and solar generation systems.
- Tesla will see higher profit margins as it achieves its plan to reduce battery costs by 56% over the next several years.
- Through the combination of its industry-leading technology and unique supercharger network, Tesla offers the best function of any EV on the market, which should result in its maintaining its market leader status as EV adoption increases.
Company Profile
Founded in 2003 and based in Palo Alto, California, Tesla is a vertically integrated sustainable energy company that also aims to transition the world to electric mobility by making electric vehicles. The company sells solar panels and solar roofs for energy generation plus batteries for stationary storage for residential and commercial properties including utilities. Tesla has multiple vehicles in its fleet, which include luxury and midsize sedans and crossover SUVs. The company also plans to begin selling more affordable sedans and small SUVs, a light truck, a semi truck, and a sports car. Global deliveries in 2020 were roughly 500,000 units.
(Source: Morningstar)
General Advice Warning
Any advice/ information provided is general in nature only and does not take into account the personal financial situation, objectives or needs of any particular person.
Ceridian offers payroll and human capital management solutions via its flagship Dayforce platform, secondary platform Powerpay targeting small businesses in Canada, and remaining legacy Bureau products such as tax services. The company benefits from high customer switching costs, allowing it to retain clients, upsell add-on modules, and earn a steady stream of recurring revenue at a low marginal cost, underpinning our narrow moat rating. Morningstar analysts expect Ceridian’s growing record of performance should help to attract new business, increase market share, and expand into new global markets. The shares currently screen as overvalued, trading at a 30% premium to our fair value estimate.
Ceridian has disrupted incumbent providers and taken share of the expansive and growing HCM market through the appeal of its agile, cloud-based solutions that offer an alternative to legacy on-premises solutions or solutions cobbled together using multiple databases or platforms. The company derives most of its revenue from Dayforce, which is geared to larger enterprises wishing to streamline complex human resources operations across multiple jurisdictions on a unified platform and leverage the platform’s scalable infrastructure. Dayforce offers real-time continuous payroll calculation and, as a natural extension, on-demand pay. Leveraging this functionality, Ceridian introduced Dayforce Wallet in 2020, which allows clients’ employees to load their net earned wages to a prepaid Mastercard, generating interchange fee revenue for Ceridian when purchases are made. While this innovation is being replicated by competitors, we expect it will create a promising new high-margin revenue stream for Ceridian that leverages the firm’s exposure to millions of employees and their earned wages.
Morningstar analysts estimate revenue to grow at an 18% compound annual rate over the five years to fiscal 2025, driven by mid-single digit industry growth, market share gains, and mid-single digit group revenue per client growth. As per Morningstar analyst perspective, 12% average annual growth in Dayforce recurring revenue per client due to an increasing skew to larger businesses and greater module uptake. This growth will be offset by low single-digit revenue growth per Powerpay client due to minimal price increases and modest module uptake. Across both platforms, Morningstar expects fierce competitive pressures to limit like-for-like pricing growth to low single digits. Over the same period, expect operating margins to increase to about 14% from less than 1% in a COVID-19-affected 2020 and 9% in a pre-COVID 2019. We anticipate this uplift will be driven by operating leverage from increased scale and higher interest on client funds.
Ceridian has made a tactical shift to target larger businesses and move further upmarket into the large enterprise and global space. While this drives higher revenue per client and exposes the company to a larger pool of client funds, we expect fierce competitive pressures and powerful clients will lead to increased pricing pressure, limiting margin upside potential over the long run. Morningstar analysts assume Ceridian will achieve midcycle operating margins around 31% in 2030, which is comparable with our forecast for wide-moat Workday, which also targets large enterprises with its cloud-based HCM software. By comparison, morningstar analyst forecast wide-moat Paychex, which targets small and midsize clients with significantly lower bargaining power, will achieve mid cycle operating margins of 43%. Ceridian operates in a highly competitive market, and expect it will need to maintain high levels of investment to ensure that the functionality of its product suite is comparable with peers’ and meets clients’ needs.
Company profile
Ceridian HCM provides payroll and human capital management solutions targeting clients with 100-100,000 employees. Following the 2012 acquisition of Dayforce, Ceridian pivoted away from its legacy on-premises Bureau business to become a cloud HCM provider. As of fiscal 2020, nearly 80% of group revenue was derived from the flagship Dayforce platform geared toward enterprise clients. The remaining revenue is about evenly split between cloud platform Powerpay, targeting small businesses in Canada, and legacy Bureau products.
(Source: Morningstar)
General Advice Warning
Any advice/ information provided is general in nature only and does not take into account the personal financial situation, objectives or needs of any particular person.
Business Strategy and Outlook
After decades of deriving most of its income from natural gas distribution and midstream businesses, NiSource has transitioned to a more diversified earnings mix. About 60% of NiSource’s operating income comes from its six natural gas distribution utilities and 40% from its electric utility in Indiana following the 2015 separation from Columbia Pipeline Group. NiSource’s utilities have constructive regulatory frameworks that allow it to collect a cash return of and a cash return on the bulk of its capital investments within 18 months.
In October 2020, NiSource sold its Columbia Gas of Massachusetts utility and received $1.1 billion of proceeds that it used to strengthen the balance sheet and prepare for its planned infrastructure investments. The sale came nearly two years after a natural gas explosion on NiSource’s Massachusetts system killed one person north of Boston. Insurance covered roughly half of the almost $2 billion of claims, penalties, and other expenses. Earnings are set to rebound quickly from their low in 2020 when COVID-19 pandemic costs, lower energy use, the Massachusetts utility sale, and a large equity issuance weighed on earnings. We expect modest customer growth combined with NiSource’s infrastructure growth investments to support 8% annual earnings growth and 6% annual dividend growth from 2021 to 2025.
Financial Strength
NiSource has issued a substantial amount of equity in the past few years in part to fund its large infrastructure growth projects and in part to cover liabilities arising from the Massachusetts gas explosion. This dilution and the sale of Columbia Gas of Massachusetts has kept earnings mostly flat since 2018.NiSource’s debt/capital topped 67% at year-end 2017, but huge equity infusions have brought that down to more sustainable levels in the mid-50% range. NiSource issued over $1 billion of common stock and $880 million of preferred stock in 2018 and 2019. The Massachusetts utility sale in 2020 raised $1.1 billion, and NiSource issued $862.5 million of convertible preferred equity units in early 2021.
NiSource has grown its dividend nearly 40% since the 2015 Columbia Pipeline Group spin-off, but the growth has not been consistent. The company increased its dividend in mid-2016 by 6.5% and again by 6.1% in the first quarter of 2017, then by 11.4% in 2018. But the 2019 dividend increase was only 2.6% following the Boston gas explosion. NiSource is past the peak of its five-year capital spending plan and its equity needs shrink.
Bulls Say’s
- The dividend to grow near 5% annually during the next few years before accelerating to keep pace with earnings in 2024 and beyond.
- NiSource should benefit from Indiana policymakers’ desire to cut the state’s carbon emissions by replacing coal generation with renewable energy, energy storage, and possibly hydrogen.
- New legislation has improved the regulatory framework in Indiana for NiSource’s electric and natural gas distribution utilities.
Company Profile
NiSource is one of the nation’s largest natural gas distribution companies with approximately 3.5 million customers in Indiana, Kentucky, Maryland, Ohio, Pennsylvania, and Virginia. NiSource’s electric utility transmits and distributes electricity in northern Indiana to about 500,000 customers. The regulated electric utility also owns more than 3,000 megawatts of generation capacity, most of which is now coal-fired but is being replaced by natural gas and renewables.
(Source: Morningstar)
General Advice Warning
Any advice/ information provided is general in nature only and does not take into account the personal financial situation, objectives or needs of any particular person.
