Categories
Dividend Stocks

Solid Quarter for National Australia Bank With Margin Pressure Offset by Valuable Loan Growth

Business Strategy and Outlook

National Australia Bank is one of four major banks operating in oligopolistic Australia and New Zealand markets. It is Australia’s biggest business bank, offering a full range of banking and financial services to the consumer, small business, and corporate sectors, with significant operations in New Zealand. 

The bank has consistently held onto its large share of business loans, and continued investment shows a clear intention to retain this position. Capacity to make investments into digital onboarding and fast access to unsecured lending ensure the bank retains high satisfaction amongst small business customers.The macro economic impact of the coronavirus has put the near-term outlook for credit growth and profitability under a cloud. The main current influences on earnings growth are modest credit growth, a product of household risk aversion and deleveraging, and delays to business plans for capital expenditure. Intense competition is constraining interest margins. Operating expenses are expected to moderate from 2021 though after years of rising risk and compliance spend.

After enjoying super low impairment charges pre-2020, large loan losses expected due to COVID-19 resulted in large provisions in fiscal 2020. As a result of which, Morningstar analysts expect a return to midcycle levels around 0.18% in fiscal 2025. The MLC wealth divestment completed in May 2021 after reaching an agreement with IOOF for AUD 1.44 billion as the bank simplifies and refocuses on its core banking operations.

Solid Quarter for National Australia Bank With Margin Pressure Offset by Valuable Loan Growth 

National Australia Bank’s first-quarter cash profit of AUD 1.8 billion is a strong start to the year. Operationally performance in the quarter was solid. The bank continues to sustain home loan growth ahead of the market, growing by 2.6% in the quarter. But with net interest margins, or NIM, trending lower, for the earnings run rate to hold, the release of loan loss provisions will need to step up. NIM fell 5 basis points to 1.64%, Morningstar analysts maintained a fair value estimate to AUD 28 per share. Morningstar analysts continue to assume NIM improvements in fiscal 2023 on a higher cash rate with a recovery to a NIM of 1.85% by fiscal 2025. Despite cost inflation, analysts think the bank can keep operating costs flat in dollar terms in fiscal 2023 and expect the benefits of fewer systems, more streamlined loan processing to allow the bank to reduce branch costs and staff numbers over time

Financial Strength 

National Australia Bank is in good financial health, with common equity Tier 1 of 12.4% above the regulator’s 10.5% benchmark as at Dec. 31, 2021. The bank slashed the fiscal 2020 dividend to AUD 60 cents per share on both lower earnings and a reduced dividend payout ratio. Morningstar analysts expect the payout to average 70% of earnings before notable items over the next five years, in line with the target range of 65%-75% introduced in 2020. National Australia Bank has AUD 3.5 billion in excess capital, assuming a target common equity Tier 1 ratio of 11% (management target of 10.75% to 11.25%). This assumes completion of the AUD 2.5 billion share buyback announced in July 2021 and the acquisition of Citigroup’s Australian consumer business.

Bulls Say

  • Management focus is on successful, lower-risk, and profitable domestic banking. Economies of scale, pricing power, a strong balance sheet, and high credit ratings provide a robust platform to drive growth. 
  • As Australia’s biggest business bank, National Australia Bank has the most to gain from the rebound in demand for business credit. 
  • NAB has the ability to achieve significant cost savings and drive operational efficiency improvements

Company Profile

National Australia Bank is the most business-focused of the four major banks, holding the largest share of business loans and the number-three spot in home loans. National Australia Bank is currently the third-largest bank by market capitalization, with the franchise covering consumer, small business, corporate, and institutional sectors. Under the UBank brand the bank also owns one of Australia’s largest digital-only banks. Offshore operations in New Zealand round out the group.

 (Source: Morningstar)

General Advice Warning

Any advice/ information provided is general in nature only and does not take into account the personal financial situation, objectives or needs of any particular person.

Categories
Dividend Stocks

WHSP Growing Shareholders Money In Distinctive Ways Than Other Fund Managers And Capital Allocators

Business Strategy and Outlook

WHSP is a value investment style-oriented investment house with approximately AUD 9 billion in net asset value. Its approach to growing shareholder value is somewhat distinct from many fund managers and capital allocators, benefitting from advantages in its corporate structure, investment-style and from an unconstrained investment mandate. WHSP allocates capital largely in Australian equity markets–both public and private–where it feels its reputation as a long-term passive allocator of capital provides it with advantages. This reputation has been built over decades and is supported by a cross-shareholding with Brickworks–a unique corporate structure in Australian equity markets—partially shielding WHSP from the vagaries of equity markets. As a result, WHSP has greater flexibility to allocate capital in a manner abiding with true value investing paradigms, importantly including the ability to invest in a contrarian manner and with long time horizons. The group’s structure–as an investment holding company with a source of captive capital–provides further advantages. Constraints imposed by the requirement to fund redemptions in bear markets, and/or the need to ‘index hug’ in bull markets are less of a concern to WHSP, as often is the case for mutual fund structures. While these attributes are advantageous, they don’t provide a guarantee that the firm’s past successes will be replicated. 

WHSP provides capital on a long-term and passive basis, differing from private equity firms which are actively involved in management and strategy of investee enterprises. WHSP’s investment horizon also differs from uncertainty rating for WHSP. With negligible debt carried at the parent entity-level, WHSP’s cost of capital is therefore estimated at 11.0%. Analysts have incorporated the expected benefits of the Milton Corporation merger within their fair value estimate as of June 23, 2021. At the time, Analysts increased their fair value estimate by 9% to AUD 23.10 per share. It is seen that immaterial cost synergies associated with combining the two investment houses. Analysts’ valuation uplift is predominantly driven by WHSP financing the transaction with its overvalued scrip, which prior to the announcement was trading at a 43% premium to their fair value estimate.

Financial Strength

WHSP has an appropriately conservative approach to the use of debt. Net debt for the WHSP parent entity stood at AUD 26 million at fiscal 2021 year-end. Historically, WHSP’s approach has been for the parent-entity to remain ungeared and to hold significant cash balances at times. Holding significant cash balances at certain points in the equity market cycle is a central component of the value investment style and WHSP’s model for long-term shareholder value creation. Nonetheless, the advent of ultra-low interest rates in recent years has made the holding cash punitive. Therefore, the group uses debt facilities to access liquidity to take advantage of periods when equity market prices detach from long-term fundamentals. Nonetheless, WHSP parent-level gearing will remain modest with an upper limit of 15% (net debt equity) in place. The financial leverage of the group’s parent-entity is the most appropriate indicator of the financial health of WHSP. The financial exposure of WHSP to the fixed obligations, including debt, of its investments is inadvertently misstated in its consolidated financial statements. Under IFRS accounting standards, variation exists in terms of the extent and manner of reporting balance sheet items of WHSP’s investments in the group’s consolidated financial statements. The level of ownership in each investment dictates whether balance sheet items are fully consolidated or not. Regardless of the extent of WHSP’s ownership in each of its individual investments, there exists no material recourse or guarantees from WHSP of the debt or other fixed obligations of any of its investments. WHSP aims to pay steadily increasing dividends to shareholders from operating cash flow of the WHSP parent entity. The financial statements of the WHSP parent entity reflect WHSP’s status as an investor and the cash flows which WHSP receive as an investor in the multitude of businesses which it invests in

Bulls Say’s

  • WHSP’s uncompromising value investment style will likely see shareholder value creation continue. 
  • A cross-shareholding provides a strong defence against the short-term whims of equity markets. 
  • TPG’s recent merger with Vodafone Australia could improve the merged entity’s competitive position

Company Profile 

Washington H. Soul Pattinson, or WHSP, is a value-oriented investment house which invests in public and privately held companies. As an investor, WHSP allocates capital with a view to taking a long-term position in its investments and on a passive basis. A long-held cross-shareholding in one of its investments–Brickworks–has provided a shield to WHSP from the short term-ism that is often pervasive in equity markets. In 2021, WHSP merged with fellow investment house, Milton Corporation 

(Source: MorningStar)

General Advice Warning

Any advice/ information provided is general in nature only and does not take into account the personal financial situation, objectives or needs of any particular person.

Categories
Dividend Stocks Shares

Dividend of BCE Inc. has been increasing 5% each year since 2015 and is expected to be the norm through 2026

Business Strategy and Outlook

BCE has been investing heavily to upgrade its wireline network by extending fiber to the home, or FTTH, which positions the firm to take share over its footprint. BCE also remains a leader in providing wireless service throughout Canada and has a formidable media business. 

BCE is the biggest Canadian broadband provider, with nearly 4 million high-speed Internet customers at the end of 2021 and a footprint that reaches three fourths of the nation’s population. Its two biggest competitors, cable companies Rogers (in Ontario), and Videotron (in Quebec) have about 2.5 million and 1.8 million subscribers, respectively. As a legacy phone provider, BCE has historically had an inferior network, contributing to better penetration rates for Rogers and Videotron. FTTH will meaningfully reduce operating costs, allow BCE to offer speeds comparable to or better than competitors, and charge higher prices. 

BCE is second to none in Canadian wireless and expects it to remain atop the market with Rogers and Telus. However, it is expected the wireless market to remain competitive and believe pricing will remain under pressure for the incumbents, even if the Shaw merger with Rogers is completed, due to regulatory scrutiny. Long term, average revenue per user will be stagnant, which will limit the firm’s ability to expand wireless margins. 

BCE also distinguishes itself from competitors with a high-quality and diversified media unit (Rogers is the only other Canadian telecom firm with media exposure, and BCE has superior assets). Crave is BCE’s over-the-top video-on-demand service available throughout Canada with a wealth of content, including from HBO, Showtime, and Starz. BCE is also the exclusive provider of HBO Max content in Canada and owns Canada’s top network (CTV) and top sports station (TSN). In total, BCE owns or has exclusive Canadian rights to 30 television channels, over 100 radio stations, an out-of-home advertising business, and broadcast rights for a multitude of sports teams, leagues, and even

Financial Strength

Although BCE ended 2021 with a net debt/EBITDA ratio of 3.0, above the 1.75-2.25 that it targets, and is expected the leverage ratio to stay above the firm’s target range throughout our five-year forecast, the firm’s financial position as strong and likely to improve. At the end of 2021, the company had CAD 207 million in cash, and an interest coverage ratio (adjusted EBITDA to interest expense) of over 9.0. BCE has CAD 1.5 billion to CAD 2.6 billion maturing each year between 2022 and 2025, but it is not anticipated it will have difficulty rolling the obligations over. BCE also had about 3.5 billion of available liquidity at the end of 2021 thanks to its committed credit facility. Higher debt levels in recent years are attributable to acquisitions (the biggest of which was the acquisition of a portion of MTS’ business for close to CAD 1.5 billion in cash), spectrum purchases, its fiber-to-the-home network buildout, and cash needs for pension funding. BCE will continually participate in spectrum auctions, it is not foreseen any upcoming auctions that will be as big as 2021’s 3500 MHz auction, where BCE spent CAD 2 billion. It is also expected capital spending to come down significantly after 2022, as the firm passes the accelerated portion of its fiber buildout, and any big mergers or pension contributions is not expected, as the company has eliminated its pension deficit. These should result in higher free cash flow that can go toward paying down debt. The company has sufficient flexibility should opportunities arise. BCE has increased its dividend by at least 5% each year since having to cut it during the financial crisis in 2008. The increase has been right at 5% each year since 2015, and is expected to be the norm through 2026. 

Bulls Say’s

  • The immense network improvement that will result from BCE’s fiber-to-the-home buildout will lead to wireline share gains and margin improvement. 
  • With the Canadian wireless market far less penetration than the U.S. and Europe, a long growth runway exists. As an industry leader, BCE is well positioned to take advantage. 
  • BCE’s fiber-to-the-home buildout leaves it well positioned for a transition to 5G, which will require significant fiber capacity.

Company Profile 

BCE is both a wireless and Internet service provider, offering wireless, broadband, television, and landline phone services in Canada. It is one of the big three national wireless carriers, with its roughly 10 million customers constituting about 30% of the market. It is also the ILEC (incumbent local exchange carrier–the legacy telephone provider) throughout much of the eastern half of Canada, including in the most populous Canadian provinces–Ontario and Quebec. Additionally, BCE has a media segment, which holds television, radio, and digital media assets. BCE licenses the Canadian rights to movie channels including HBO, Showtime, and Starz. In 2021, the wireline segment accounted for 54% of total EBITDA, while wireless composed 39%, and media provided the remainder.

(Source: Morningstar)

General Advice Warning

Any advice/ information provided is general in nature only and does not take into account the personal financial situation, objectives or needs of any particular person.

Categories
Dividend Stocks Expert Insights

Suncorp’s Battered Bottom Line Masks Positive Momentum Across the Group

Business Strategy and Outlook:

There are positive signs for the future of Suncorp and perhaps early validation of management’s strategic investments though. Australian gross written premiums, or GWP, increased 5%, with the insurer benefiting from premium rate increases as well as growth in policy numbers. In New Zealand, increases were even larger, with GWP up 14%. Improved digital sales and service capabilities, including claims lodgment and tracking, should bring cost savings and improve the customer experience. Lifting marketing of key brands and simplifying product offerings are also likely helping. Cost inflation in home and motor insurance in the mid-single digit percent range has so far been offset by rate increases and further negated by work the insurer is doing to manage costs. Tools to better allocate work to builders and benchmark repair costs are examples.

Suncorp has a point with areas government should focus on. Improve public infrastructure, provide subsidies to improve resilience of private dwellings, address planning laws and approval processes, and remove inefficient taxes and charges on insurance premiums.

Financial Strength:

Suncorp has a track record of returning surplus capital to shareholders via special dividends and share buybacks. The fully franked final dividend of AUD 23 cents is down from AUD 26 cents per share last year, with the payout ratio at the top end of the 60%-80% target range. Home loans grew at an annualised rate of 5.3%, but net interest margins, or NIM, tumbled 12 basis points to 1.97%. Growth in premiums and home loans have come at cost. Operating expenses increased 5.8% as Suncorp ramps up spend on digital initiatives and marketing, and insurance commissions grow with premiums. Digital sales made up 38% of Australian insurance sales in the half, up from 33% in first-half fiscal 2021, with some brands already at 50%.

Company Profile:

Suncorp is a Queensland-based financial services conglomerate offering retail and business banking, general insurance, superannuation, and investment products in Australia and New Zealand. It also operates a life insurance business in New Zealand. The core businesses include personal insurance, commercial insurance, Vero New Zealand, and Suncorp Bank. Suncorp and competitors IAG Insurance and QBE Insurance dominate the Australian and New Zealand insurance markets.

(Source: Morningstar)

General Advice Warning

Any advice/ information provided is general in nature only and does not take into account the personal financial situation, objectives or needs of any particular person.

Categories
Dividend Stocks

TransDigm’s Commercial Aerospace Business Seen Performing Well During First Quarter

Business Strategy and Outlook

TransDigm Group operates as a holding company with a clear, consistent strategy: acquire businesses with proprietary aircraft components, primarily sole-source products, with high aftermarket content. TransDigm’s businesses manufacture and sell replacement parts for ignition systems, pumps, actuators, and flight controls, among other things. Since aircraft must be fully maintained to be operational and TransDigm is the only provider of many of their products, the company has significant pricing power. The firm operates with a high degree of financial leverage to amplify operating results. 

This strategy works because potential competing spare parts must be licensed by the Federal Aviation Administration to be identical to the original product. Since TransDigm’s designs are proprietary, it is challenging for would-be competitors to prove that their design is identical. This barrier to entry allows TransDigm to extract value from regulator-required maintenance and enables the firm to aggressively price spare parts. TransDigm had its IPO in 2006, after 13 years of private ownership, and it still uses private equity strategies of creating value. The firm aims to improve the operations of its target companies by increasing prices, productivity, and encourage employees to generate new business. TransDigm is highly decentralized and has numerous business units. It encourages business unit leaders to think like owners by setting aggressive targets for managers and allowing them to achieve these goals however they choose to. 

The coronavirus pandemic has substantially reduced travel and consequently grounded a large chunk of the global passenger fleet, though domestic air travel is rebounding. The progression of the global fleet age remains an open question with large ramifications for TransDigm. If airlines use the current fleet to bring back capacity during a potential commercial aviation recovery, TransDigm would benefit from the continued maintenance of these aircraft. If airlines take delivery of new aircraft and use newer, under-warranty aircraft to bring back capacity, it is likely to reduce TransDigm’s addressable market for several years.

Financial Strength

TransDigm considers itself a private-equity-like public company, so its capital allocation is meaningfully different than most aerospace and defense companies that are covered. TransDigm continuously utilizes financial leverage–gross debt is usually 7-8 times unadjusted EBITDA. While Analysts’ are normally concerned about such high leverage, it is alleged TransDigm’s private equity roots make it quite capable of handling debt. Management has been in place and using the same leveraged strategy since the founding of the firm in 1993. It is not anticipated that the company will reduce leverage meaningfully. The company has been diligent at keeping debt maturities several years away. The company does not have a material debt maturity coming due until 2024, which is seen, gives the company ample time to recover from the COVID-19 challenges to aviation. TransDigm was able to raise debt during April 2020, when airlines were struggling the most. It is alleged that TransDigm would be able to raise additional debt from capital markets if necessary because of the highly visible pricing power and intellectual property backing the firm.

Bulls Say’s

  • Roughly three quarters of TransDigm’s sales are solesource, which gives it immense pricing power. 
  • About 90% of TransDigm’s products are proprietary, which protects its sole-source incumbency. 
  • TransDigm has historically been able to acquire companies at reasonable prices and meaningfully improve operations

Company Profile 

TransDigm manufactures and services a diverse set of components for commercial and military aircraft. The firm organizes itself in three segments: a power and control segment, an airframe segment, and a small nonaviation segment. It operates as an acquisitive holding company that targets firms with proprietary, sole-source products with substantial aftermarket content. TransDigm regularly employs financial leverage to amplify operating results. 

(Source: MorningStar)

General Advice Warning

Any advice/ information provided is general in nature only and does not take into account the personal financial situation, objectives or needs of any particular person.

Categories
Dividend Stocks

Freight Demand To Remain Strong In Near Term, Benefitting Cummins

Business Strategy and Outlook

It is viewed Cummins will continue to be the top supplier of truck engines and components, despite increasing emissions regulation from government authorities. For over a century, the company has been the pre-eminent manufacturer of diesel engines, which has led to its place as one of the best heavy- and medium-duty engine brands. Cummins’ strong brand is underpinned by its high-performing and extremely durable engines. Customers also value Cummins’ ability to enhance the value of their trucks, leading to product differentiation. 

The company’s strategy focuses on delivering a comprehensive solution for original equipment manufacturers. It is likely, Cummins will continue to gain market share, as it captures a larger share of vehicle content. This is largely due to growing emissions regulation, which allows Cummins to sell more of its emissions solutions, namely its aftertreatment systems that convert pollutants into harmless emissions. Additionally, Cummins stands to benefit from the electrification of powertrains in the industry. The company has made progress in the school and transit bus markets. Long term, it is probable the truck market to also increase electrification. The pressure to manufacture more environmentally friendly products is forcing truck OEMs to evaluate whether it’s economically viable to continue producing their own engines and components or to partner with a market leader like Cummins. It is viewed this play out recently, through the increase in partnership announcements for medium-duty engines with truck OEMs. It is seen, some OEMs will opt to shift investment away from engine and component development, leaving it to Cummins. 

Cummins has exposure to end markets that have attractive tailwinds. In trucking, it is likely new truck orders will be strong in the near term, largely due to strong demand for consumer goods. In good times, truck operators replace aging trucks and opt to expand their fleet to meet strong demand. Longer term, it is alleged Cummins will continue to invest in BEVs and fuel cells to power future truck models. It is foreseen a zero-emission world is inevitable, but is believed Cummins can use returns from its diesel business to drive investments.

Financial Strength

Cummins maintains a sound balance sheet. In 2021, total outstanding debt stood at $3.6 billion, but the firm had $2.6 billion of cash on the balance sheet. In 2020, the company issued $2 billion of long-term debt at attractively low rates, some of which was used to pay down its commercial paper obligations. Cummins’ strong balance sheet gives management the financial flexibility to run a balanced capital allocation strategy going forward that mostly favors organic growth and returns cash to shareholders. In terms of liquidity, it is seen the company can meet its near-term debt obligations given its strong cash balance. It is also viewed, comfort in Cummins’ ability to tap into available lines of credit to meet any short-term needs. Cummins has access to $3.2 billion in credit facilities. Cummins can also generate solid free cash flow throughout the economic cycle. It is alleged the company can generate over $2 billion in free cash flow in Analysts’ midcycle year, supporting its ability to return nearly all of its free cash flow to shareholders through dividends and share repurchases. Additionally, it is likely management is determined to improve its distribution business following its transformation efforts in recent years. It is probable Cummins can improve the profitability of the business through efficiency gains, pushing EBITDA margins higher in the near term. These actions further support its ability to return cash to shareholders. In Analysts’ view, Cummins enjoys a strong financial position supported by a clean balance sheet and strong free cash flow prospects.

Bulls Say’s

  • Strong freight demand in the truck market should lead to more new truck orders, substantially boosting Cummins’ revenue growth. 
  • Cummins will benefit from increasing emission regulation, pushing customers to buy emissions solutions, such as aftertreatment systems that turn engine pollutants into harmless emissions. 
  • Increasing emission standards could push peers to rethink whether it’s economically viable to continue manufacturing engines and components, benefiting Cummins.

Company Profile 

Cummins is the top manufacturer of diesel engines used in commercial trucks, off-highway equipment, and railroad locomotives, in addition to standby and prime power generators. The company also sells powertrain components, which include filtration products, transmissions, turbochargers, aftertreatment systems, and fuel systems. Cummins is in the unique position of competing with its primary customers, heavy-duty truck manufacturers, who make and aggressively market their own engines. Despite robust competition across all its segments and increasing government regulation of diesel emissions, Cummins has maintained its leadership position in the industry.

(Source: MorningStar)

General Advice Warning

Any advice/ information provided is general in nature only and does not take into account the personal financial situation, objectives or needs of any particular person.

Categories
Dividend Stocks Philosophy Technical Picks

La Nina and Investment Markets Wipe Out Profits, but Suncorp Inches Closer to Management Targets

Business Strategy and Outlook

Suncorp is a well-capitalised financial services business with a dominant market position in the Australian and New Zealand general insurance industry and a regional banking franchise headquartered in Queensland. In addition to offering insurance under the parent name, key brands in Australia include AAMI, GIO, bingle, Apia, Shannons and Terri Scheer. In New Zealand key brands include Vero, AA Insurance and Asteron Life. Some brands are specific to certain states, but at a group level, the insurer carries concentrated weather and earthquake risk in Australia and New Zealand, and in particular Queensland which makes up around 25% of gross written premiums in Australia. 

The group’s exposure to the Queensland market, where large natural peril events have tended to be larger and more frequent, heightens the risks. Reinsurance protection mitigates risks to some extent, but can be expensive, particularly following large events. Suncorp’s regional banking franchise is more concentrated than the major banks, with home loans making up around 80% of the loan book and Queensland accounting for more than half of total lending. Suncorp Bank’s smaller operating presence, higher funding and operational costs, and relatively limited product offerings have all led to lower margins relative to the majors.

Financial Strength 

Suncorp Group is in good financial health. As at Dec. 31, 2021, Suncorp Insurance had a prescribed capital amount, or PCA, multiple of 1.71 times the regulatory minimum. Following the payment of the final dividend, a special dividend, and AUD 250 million buyback, at a group level that leaves Suncorp with AUD 492 million of capital in excess of its common equity Tier 1 target. This excess capital provides a buffer for unforeseen insurance and bad debt events. The common equity Tier 1 ratio for the insurance business was 1.28 times post the final dividend payment, within the target range of 1.08-1.28 times the PCA, and well above the regulatory minimum of 0.6 times. The bank’s common equity Tier 1 ratio as at Dec. 31, 2021 was 9.9%, above Suncorp’s 9% to 9.5% target range. Suncorp targets a dividend payout of 60-80% cash earnings (excluding special dividends).

Bulls Say’s

  • Suncorp owns a portfolio of well-known insurance brands and a regional bank that lacks switching or cost advantages. A focus on processes and systems, largely digitising customer interactions, should support underlying earnings growth. 
  • General insurance is inherently risky, with factors such as weather, natural disasters, and investment markets affecting earnings and capital adequacy. 
  • Brand recognition and confidence claims will be paid are helpful in acquiring and retaining customers, but customers are price sensitive.

Company Profile 

Suncorp is a Queensland-based financial services conglomerate offering retail and business banking, general insurance, superannuation, and investment products in Australia and New Zealand. It also operates a life insurance business in New Zealand. The core businesses include personal insurance, commercial insurance, Vero New Zealand, and Suncorp Bank. Suncorp and competitors IAG Insurance and QBE Insurance dominate the Australian and New Zealand insurance markets.

(Source: Morningstar)

General Advice Warning

Any advice/ information provided is general in nature only and does not take into account the personal financial situation, objectives or needs of any particular person.

Categories
Dividend Stocks

SkyCity is priced attractively for patient investors

Business Strategy and Outlook:

COVID-19 continues to weigh heavily on the firm’s near-term outlook. The Auckland casino–SkyCity’s core property–waded through over 100 days in lockdown during the period, heavily affecting visitor numbers at the group’s venues in the first half of fiscal 2022. Additionally, visitor numbers to the group’s second-biggest venue in Adelaide were subdued as capacity restrictions and domestic border closures in South Australia persistent for most of the first half of fiscal 2022. These are viewed as short-term issues, and it is expected SkyCity to bounce back when restrictions ease. SkyCity’s long-dated and exclusive licences in Auckland and Adelaide create a regulatory barrier to entry, underpinning the firm’s narrow economic moat, and position the business well to participate in the recovery as restrictions ease.

The Adelaide casino has remained open, albeit with restrictions for much of the first half of fiscal 2022. Renovations are complete and the group is poised to receive extra income from additional parking spots once city visitors return at greater levels. For now, the parking spots are being given away for a song, subject to visiting the casino facilities. New Zealand moved to a traffic-light COVID-19 protection framework in December 2021. This will reduce lockdowns and restrictions as the country allows more freedom for those who are vaccinated. Under red, the most extreme level of the traffic light system, hospitality venues may remain open with restrictions. While preferable to a full closure, we think it will still dampen revenue as many visitors choose to stay home out of an abundance of caution.

Financial Strength:

With a balance sheet well-positioned to weather the storm, analysts think current depressed prices present an opportunity for patient investors to gain exposure to a high-quality gaming business at a discount. However, the path to full capacity is likely to be gradual and material short-term catalysts are lacking. The analysts expect the recovery of SkyCity’s EBITDA to its prepandemic levels to take until fiscal 2023. In the second half of fiscal 2022, it is expected that the combined benefit of additional parking bays and the casino renovation to raise Adelaide’s EBITDA margins to 20% from 16%, in line with guidance. Visitors to the city of Adelaide have been subdued, at around 50% of prepandemic levels in the year to August 2021. 

Company Profile:

SkyCity Entertainment operates a number of casino-hotel complexes across Australia and New Zealand. The flagship property is SkyCity Auckland, the holder and operator of an exclusive casino licence (expiring in 2048) in New Zealand’s most populous city. The company also owns smaller casinos in Hamilton and Queenstown. In Australia, the company operates SkyCity Adelaide (exclusive licence expiring in 2035).

(Source: Morningstar)

General Advice Warning

Any advice/ information provided is general in nature only and does not take into account the personal financial situation, objectives or needs of any particular person.

Categories
Dividend Stocks Shares

Capable Hands Remain at the Helm of Magellan; Valuation Upside High as Shares Lose Steam

Business Strategy and Outlook

Magellan is an active manager of listed equities and infrastructure. The firm has a fundamental, high-conviction investment approach. Its flagship Global strategy has historically tilted toward IT, e-commerce platforms, and consumer franchises; preferring large, developed market multinationals. FUM have been attracted by consistently achieving excess returns with lower volatility and drawdowns relative to peers.

Magellan’s products are well-distributed. Its funds are featured across platforms.There is a focus on targeting retail investors, with product expansion an increasingly common driver of growth. After pioneering the first active ETF in Australia in 2015, Magellan has worked on attracting new FUM via its partnership initiatives, launching its own low-cost active ETFs, and introducing a new equity fund that caters to retirees seeking predictable income.

Morningstar analysts think Magellan has built the foundations for ongoing earnings growth, supported by its economic moat, product variety, and historically strong track record. Regardless, the potential earnings upside from these positive traits will take time to manifest. In light of Magellan’s recent underperformance, Mornigstars analysts believe a sustained improved track record will be the precursor to stronger fund inflows.

Morningstar analysts anticipate fee margin compression from investors trading down from Magellan’s core funds in preference for its low-cost ETFs, mix shift to other asset classes, and industry wide fee pressure. Continued strong performance is key to sustaining margins, as future FUM growth is likely to hinge more on market movements rather than net inflows given Magellan’s maturity and scale.

Capable Hands Remain at the Helm of Magellan; Valuation Upside High as Shares Lose Steam

Magellan has historically delivered above market returns with relatively low drawdowns. This has allowed it to rapidly scale in FUM to over AUD 93 billion and provides the foundation for continued earnings growth. While Morningstar analysts don’t believe it will be immune from the structural trend of investors moving to passive investments, ongoing competition among fund managers and major institutions in-housing their asset management, and is better placed than most active managers to address these headwinds. Magellan is moving beyond just managing money, to implementing new initiatives such as product expansion to attract new money. Morningstar analysts  believe shares are undervalued, but concur there are limited near-term earnings and share price catalysts due to recent underperformance. 

Chairman and CIO Hamish Douglass’ indefinite leave from Magellan . But morningstar analysts  don’t believe this is overly value-destructive for shareholders. In the interim, Chris Mackay and Nikki Thomas will work with Magellan’s investment team to manage its flagship Global Equity strategies. The strategies are in good hands. Mackay is Magellan’s co-founder, and was its chairman and CIO until 2012. Despite analysts’ conviction in Magellan, Morningstar’s analyst concern is not all investors may be willing to ride out this storm. Thus Morningstar analysts have lowered its fair value estimate to AUD 34.50 per share from AUD 38, after factoring in 3% more net outflows than before and further trimming our retail fee forecasts.

Financial Strength 

Magellan is in sound financial health. The firm has a conservative balance sheet with no debt, with its financial position also boosted by solid operating cash flows. As of June 30, 2021, Magellan had cash and equivalents of about AUD 212 million and financial investments with a net fair value of around AUD 453 million mainly invested in its own unlisted funds and listed shares. This should provide it with enough liquidity to cope with most market conditions. Its high dividend payout ratio of: (1) 90%-95% of the net profit after tax of its core funds management business before performance fees; and (2) annual performance fee dividend in the range of 90%-95% of net crystallised performance fees after tax reflects the capital-light nature of asset management.

Bulls Say

  • Magellan retains an intangible brand, supported by historically strong performance, which it has leveraged to hold on to client funds, attract new money and charge premium fees. 
  • Due to structural market trends and product expansion initiatives, the prospects for organic FUM growth is strong, notably from investors seeking to diversify exposure to international equities or gain a steady retirement income stream. 
  • Aside from domestic tailwinds from superannuation, Magellan’s distribution relationships in the much larger offshore markets of the U.K. and the U.S. should support growth.

Company Profile

Magellan Financial Group is an Australia-based niche funds manager. Established in 2006, the firm specialises in the management of equity and infrastructure funds for domestic retail and institutional investors. Magellan has been particularly successful in winning mandates from global institutional investors. Current FUM is split across global equities, infrastructure and Australian equities.

(Source: Morningstar)

General Advice Warning

Any advice/ information provided is general in nature only and does not take into account the personal financial situation, objectives or needs of any particular person.

Categories
Dividend Stocks

2021 a Year of Strong Growth for C.H. Robinson; Outlook Positive, but Expect Normalization in 2022

Business Strategy and Outlook

C.H. Robinson dominates the $80-plus billion asset-light highway brokerage market, and its immense network of shippers and asset-based truckers supports a wide economic moat, in our view. Although the company isn’t immune to freight downturns, its variable-cost model helps shield profitability during periods of lack lustre demand, as evidenced by a long history of above-average profitability. The firm does not own transportation equipment, and a large portion of operating expenses are tied to performance-based variable compensation, which tends to move in line with net revenue growth. The firm is thought to be well positioned to capitalize on truck brokerage industry consolidation (including market share gains) despite intensifying competition.

Over and above underlying shipment demand trends, share gains will probably remain the key growth driver for Robinson long term. For perspective, it is estimated that Robinson’s stake of the domestic freight brokerage industry at roughly 18% in recent years, up from 13% in 2004, based on market data from Armstrong & Associates. The truck brokerage business is still vastly fragmented, and small, less sophisticated providers are finding it increasingly difficult to keep up with rising demand for efficient capacity access and the need to automate processes. Robinson’s industry-leading network of asset-based truckload carriers (most small) should remain highly valuable to shippers over the long run. This is particularly because truckload-market capacity will probably continue to see growth constraints due in part to the stubbornly limited driver pool.

Robinson has also positioned its air and ocean forwarding unit to contribute to growth. In this segment, it competes with other top-shelf providers like Expeditors International. In 2012, it purchased Phoenix International, which doubled Robinson’s forwarding scale, and organic growth has continued (on average), along with additional tuck-in deals that have boosted the firm’s global footprint. Buying scale and lane density are important in order to secure adequate capacity for shippers, particularly during the peak season.

Financial Strength

C.H. Robinson has taken a more active stance with its balance sheet over the past decade, increasing leverage in part to fund occasional opportunistic acquisitions. Before 2012, the firm was largely debt free. That said, its capital structure remains quite healthy. At the end of 2021, the firm had a manageable total debt load near $1.9 billion and $257 million in cash. Debt/EBITDA was near 1.6 times (versus 1.4 times in 2019 and 2020), and in line with management’s targeted range of 1.0-1.5 times. Interest coverage (EBITDA/interest expense) in 2021 was a comfortable 20 times. Importantly, as a well-managed asset-light 3PL, Robinson has a long history of consistent free cash flow generation, averaging more than 3.0% of gross revenue over the past five years (20% of net revenue). Note that truck brokers’ free cash flow tends to be lowest in strong years of growth by nature of the intermediary business model and related spike in accounts receivable. It is expected that free cash flow to approximate 3%-4% of gross revenue over our forecast horizon. Robinson is expected to have no issues servicing its long-term obligations, given its top-tier profitability, and the firm’s liquidity should be more than ample to weather cyclical demand pullbacks

Bulls Say’s

  •  C.H. Robinson enjoys a long history of impressive execution throughout the freight cycle, and it has thwarted a host of competitive threats over the years. 
  • It is estimated that C.H. Robinson has gradually increased its share of the truck brokerage industry to roughly 17% from 13% in 2004. 
  • Robinson’s non-asset-based operating model has generated average returns on capital near 27% during the past decade and 21% since 2017 (around 23% in 2021)–well above returns generated by most traditional asset-intensive carriers.

Company Profile 

C.H. Robinson is a top-tier non-asset-based third-party logistics provider with a significant focus on domestic freight brokerage (57% of 2021 net revenue), which reflects mostly truck brokerage but also rail intermodal. Additionally, the firm also operates a large air and ocean forwarding division (34%), which has grown organically and via tuck-in acquisitions. The remainder of revenue consists of the European truck-brokerage division, transportation management services, and a legacy produce-sourcing operation.

(Source: MorningStar)

General Advice Warning

Any advice/ information provided is general in nature only and does not take into account the personal financial situation, objectives or needs of any particular person.